Blog

When it comes to interior and exterior wall lining, ceiling systems, or even flooring underlayment, MGO board (Magnesium Oxide board) and gypsum board (often known as drywall or plasterboard) are two prominent contenders. While gypsum board has been a long-standing staple in construction, MGO board is rapidly gaining traction, especially in markets like Singapore, due due to its superior performance characteristics. But how do they truly stack up against each other? Let’s dive into a direct comparison to help you make an informed decision for your next project.

Understanding the Core Composition

• Gypsum Board: Primarily composed of gypsum plaster pressed between two sheets of paper or fiberglass mats. It’s relatively soft and can be cut and installed with ease.
• MGO Board: Made from magnesium oxide, magnesium without chloride, perlite, wood fiber, and a high-strength fiberglass mesh. This unique mineral composition gives it distinct advantages.

Head-to-Head Comparison: MGO Board vs. Gypsum Board

Here’s a detailed look at how these two materials compare across critical performance metrics:

1. Fire Resistance: A Clear Winner

• MGO Board: This is where MGO board truly shines. It is inherently fire-rated and non-combustible. It does not feed flames, emit smoke, or release toxic fumes when exposed to high temperatures. Many MGO boards can withstand fire for extended periods (e.g., 1-4 hours), making them a top choice for fire-resistant assemblies in commercial buildings and high-rise residential projects in Singapore.
• Gypsum Board: While gypsum board offers some fire resistance due to the water content in its core (which turns to steam when heated, slowing down heat transfer), it will eventually degrade and crumble under prolonged fire exposure. It’s often limited to specific fire-rating requirements depending on thickness and type (e.g., Type X).

2. Water and Moisture Resistance: Essential for Tropical Climates

• MGO Board: Highly resistant to water and moisture. It does not swell, rot, delaminate, or lose its structural integrity when exposed to humidity or even direct water. This makes it an ideal choice for bathrooms, kitchens, basements, and exterior applications, particularly in humid climates like Singapore. Its resistance to mold and mildew growth is also a significant advantage.
• Gypsum Board: Standard gypsum board is very susceptible to water damage. It can swell, sag, and promote mold growth when wet. While “green board” (moisture-resistant gypsum) offers some improvement, it’s still not designed for direct water exposure or continuous high humidity.

3. Durability and Strength: Built to Last

• MGO Board: Offers excellent strength and impact resistance due to its dense, rigid composition. It is less prone to denting or breaking during handling and installation, and provides a robust surface that stands up well to daily wear and tear.
• Gypsum Board: Generally softer and more fragile. It’s easily dented or punctured, especially standard types, requiring more careful handling and potentially more repairs over its lifespan.

4. Weight and Ease of Installation: A Nuance

• MGO Board: Can be denser and slightly heavier than standard gypsum board of the same thickness. However, it can often be used in thinner profiles to achieve similar performance as thicker gypsum, potentially balancing out the weight. It requires specific cutting tools (like a carbide-tipped saw blade) but can be screwed or nailed.
• Gypsum Board: Generally lighter and easier to cut with a utility knife, making it quicker for some types of installations. It’s widely used, so installers are very familiar with it.

5. Environmental Impact and Health: A Green Choice

• MGO Board: Considered a more eco-friendly and sustainable building material. It’s manufactured with a low-energy process, contains no formaldehyde, asbestos, or other harmful chemicals. Its mold and mildew resistance also contribute to healthier indoor air quality.
• Gypsum Board: While widely recyclable, its production can be energy-intensive. Some types may contain additives, and mold growth on gypsum can impact indoor air quality if not properly managed.

6. Cost: Initial Investment vs. Long-Term Value

• MGO Board: Typically has a higher initial material cost per sheet compared to standard gypsum board.
• Gypsum Board: Generally more affordable upfront.

However, it’s crucial to consider the long-term value: The superior durability, fire resistance, and moisture protection of MGO board can lead to significant savings on maintenance, repairs, and potential disaster recovery, ultimately offering a lower total cost of ownership, especially for critical applications in Singapore’s climate.